Springfield XD Forum banner
21 - 40 of 41 Posts
I kinda like it because I really like the trigger on 1911s and this would help cut down on weight as a carry gun. Just another option..... Either way I'm going to stick with my trusty XD for the time being :cool:
It's 2.04 pounds. That's 32+ ounces... Full size Sprignfields are 40oz. So you are only saving 8 ounces.

With all the good poly 45's on the market that were designed from day one to be a poly pistol, what is the purpose of this thing when there are so many better choices out there that have years of proven durability and reliability. Love 1911's but this isn't a 1911.

This.
 
It's 2.04 pounds. That's 32+ ounces... Full size Sprignfields are 40oz. So you are only saving 8 ounces.
I kind of wondered if that was a mistake. How is it not lighter than that with a polymer frame?

As for it "not being a 1911"? WHO CARES? Call it something else then. But if it looks like a 1911, and it shoots like a 1911, what should they call it? It is still in the 1911-style.

Regardless, I do not care it is a "real 1911" or not. I care if it is a good gun or not.

I'd like to see & hold in person, not saying I'd buy it but maybe!
All being equal, I prefer all-steel 1911's (and guns in general). However, my Walther PPQ is both polymer AND awesome. They weigh less. They function fine. So no big deal. If these things shoot amazing, are priced decently, prove rugged & reliable, and offered a significant weight-savings, I'd buy one. I have the aforementioned slight preference to steel. It is becoming a non-factor for me though to be honest. If I were considering a polymer 1911, I would be doing so largely in the presumption it would be lightweight and thus a little better (or a lot depending) for concealed carry. I would REALLY be interested in a lightweight bobtailed Commander-sized, CCO, or Officer-sized polymer 1911. I'd also be at least marginally curious to see those offered in a 9mm or .40 S&W or the like since shorter-barreled 1911's in .45 are reportedly more prone to have hiccups, and you get another round. It's non-traditional. However, I would like some incentive to go with a polymer frame over a steel-frame. A 1911 from RRA with some weight savings by itself DOES make me interested though.

-Cheers
 
Did you get a peak at the internals? I'm assuming they have metal reinforcements molded in, not like a P95?
I didn't take a look at the internals, but the frame isn't all polymer, its still steel with a polymer grip frame. If you look, you can see where the polymer wraps the steel. The frame/dust cover area is the same width as the slide.

Sent from my ADR6425LVW
 
I kind of wondered if that was a mistake. How is it not lighter than that with a polymer frame?

As for it "not being a 1911"? WHO CARES? Call it something else then. But if it looks like a 1911, and it shoots like a 1911, what should they call it? It is still in the 1911-style.

Regardless, I do not care it is a "real 1911" or not. I care if it is a good gun or not.



All being equal, I prefer all-steel 1911's (and guns in general). However, my Walther PPQ is both polymer AND awesome. They weigh less. They function fine. So no big deal. If these things shoot amazing, are priced decently, prove rugged & reliable, and offered a significant weight-savings, I'd buy one. I have the aforementioned slight preference to steel. It is becoming a non-factor for me though to be honest. If I were considering a polymer 1911, I would be doing so largely in the presumption it would be lightweight and thus a little better (or a lot depending) for concealed carry. I would REALLY be interested in a lightweight bobtailed Commander-sized, CCO, or Officer-sized polymer 1911. I'd also be at least marginally curious to see those offered in a 9mm or .40 S&W or the like since shorter-barreled 1911's in .45 are reportedly more prone to have hiccups, and you get another round. It's non-traditional. However, I would like some incentive to go with a polymer frame over a steel-frame. A 1911 from RRA with some weight savings by itself DOES make me interested though.

-Cheers
It's not that much lighter because the grip frame is polymer that wraps steel. If you look at the 2011's, the RRA is kind of similar in design.


Sent from my ADR6425LVW
 
RRA made some nice 1911s in the past, and like others have said: BUL; Wilson Combat; STI and others have all made polymer framed 1911s.

I say the more the merrier.
 
Talked to a guy who works for RRA and found out why they haven't released the polymer 1911 yet. It seems that they cannot get consistency out of the polymer frames. Because of the imperfections they break easily. They are still working on it but its been put on a far back burner until the current market cools down.
 
What applies to software, applies to new gun designs - Never, ever, buy release 1.0 of anything! Let someone else wring the problems out of the new product...
 
Kimber and BUL produced them for a while although I believe the Kimber was a double stack. With folks now producing poly AR lowers there was bound to be a poly single stack 1911 coming from someone. Considering how much anxiety there is around a plastic MSH I can't see the traditionalists being excited about an entire frame.
kimber did have them for sale for a while. they were the bp ten II series. the shorter (4') were the pro carry ten II. my understanding was the frames were BUL and kimber just mated their upper to them. i got one (bp ten II) at a gun show a few years back for $300. it was like brand new. at first it was prone to jam but after a good break in(250-300 rnds) it runs like a champ. eats everything. it is kind of boxy in the hand but for the price it is really fantastic. yes it is a double stack and yes mags are very pricey and hard to find but it is a nice gun. i think alot of people called them garbage and hated them before they broke them in so they sold them cheap. i do like my other kimbers better but this one is really fun and not one you see everyday.
 
I wonder if it sits at an angle like the XD/Glock does when its laid on its side with no mag?
 
What I love the most about the 1911, other then the great feel of the trigger and how well it shoots, is that it is all steel or an alloy. I have a lightweight Springfield that I love to carry because it weights less then the all steel 1911's. I like my alloy frame better then a plastic frame.
 
21 - 40 of 41 Posts