They both feel good to me. I haven't shot either. I have a 3" 11-87 and two 870 Super Mags, so I really don't need either one, but I'd love to have a 3.5" semi and these two are my top two choices.
Probably a good choice! I don't typically hunt with anything bigger then 3 inch either.I just talked myself off the ledge...
I'm sticking with my trusty 870 Super Mag's and my trusty old 11/87. I've shot A LOT of ducks and geese with "good ole" 12ga 3" ammo over the years.