Is there any other bullet in 40 s/w that is heavier and travels slower? Maybe 900 ft/s....?

1 - 20 of 25 Posts

Is there any other bullet in 40 s/w that is heavier and travels slower? Maybe 900 ft/s....?

My question is WHY????

If you want subsonic go with 45ACP.

-Dana

If you want subsonic go with 45ACP.

-Dana

Joined

·
2,420 Posts

Oh, maybe... because he has a .40?!

I have an xd-40. I am in the process of obtaining a suppressor for it. I need subsonic bullets to maximize the suppression.

Joined

·
16,428 Posts

Joined

·
1,454 Posts

Joined

·
2,420 Posts

For use with a suppressor.

Like was said, most 180 gr loads are subsonic. There are 200 gr bullets available if you reload.

Joined

·
430 Posts

PMC Gold 40 S&W 180 Grain Starfire Hollow Point Travels @ 985 FPS with 388FT/LBs of Muzzle Energy

Hornady TAP Personal Defense Ammunition 40 S&W 180 Grain Jacketed Hollow Point Travels @ 950FPS with 361FT/LBs of Muzzle Energy.

Hornady Custom Ammunition 40 S&W 180 Grain Jacketed Hollow Point XTP Travels @ 950FPS with 361FT/LBs of Muzzle Energy

I researched for a little bit and found those options for you. I went with all Hollow Points and top quality ones at that, which have been field proven. I personally use the Speer Gold Dot 180 Grains. I believe it travels suffiently slow enough for your purposes.

Joined

·
2,420 Posts

How is it possible for the muzzle velocity to be the same and the weight to be the same, but the muzzle energy different?Speer Gold Dot 40 S&W 180 Grain Jacketed Hollow Point Travels @ 985FPS with 400FT/LBs of Muzzle Energy.

PMC Gold 40 S&W 180 Grain Starfire Hollow Point Travels @ 985 FPS with 388FT/LBs of Muzzle Energy

Joined

·
430 Posts

Joined

·
16,428 Posts

From one site:

Energy = Bullet Weight times Velocity Squared divided by 450395

From another site:

Velocity (in F.P.S.) x Velocity x Bullet Weight (in grains) divided by 450,240

From yet another site:

E=MV2/450400

Joined

·
430 Posts

If the bullet weight is the same, assuming that the manufactures standard is up to par and isn't producing overweight or underweight rounds. IE 185 on some, and 175 on others.

Why else would there be different levels of muzzle energy?

Also powder DOES have something to do with it. Different amounts of powder produce different pressure levels. Hence the reason why +P rounds have higher pressure levels and more power. The faster the bullet travels it seems the more energy it produces according to your site references you posted.

Just like my M44 Mosin Nagant firing a 180 Grain 7.62x54R Winchester FMJ round produces a Muzzle Velocity of 2579 and a Muzzle Energy of 2658FT/LBs. Why? It has more powder, a longer barrel and the ability to make better use of the burn time of the powder and pressure created by the powder load.

Joined

·
2,420 Posts

I wouldn't have asked the question if it was a simple well known matter of physics.OK then agalindo you explain why there is different energy levels for all of those rounds I posted.

Powder imparts speed X to the bullet. The bullet weighs Y.

X and Y, I believe, are the only factors in calculating energy. Something weighs so much, and is travelling so fast, for so much energy.

If the speeds are the same, and the weights are the same... how are the energies different?

Saying "It's the powder" doesn't make any sense.

Exactly, but the bullets are supposedly the travelling the same speed.The faster the bullet travels it seems the more energy it produces according to your site references you posted.

Joined

·
430 Posts

Joined

·
4,801 Posts

Seems like the energies should be identical since the mass and velocity are the only variables.[TASF said:Overkill]

If the speeds are the same, and the weights are the same... how are the energies different?

Powder burn rates, muzzle length, anything else would be irrelevant after the projectile leaves the barrel.

I wondered about the shape of the bullet, but since that is not a part of the formula (formulas) that seems not be a factor. Although it does seem like a needle shaped bullet and a spherical bullet would impact with different degrees of energy. But since the formulas do not take shape into account at all, I suppose what

Good question. It would be interesting to really know for sure. The formulas posted are slightly different. So maybe the shape has some marginal impact on the "impact" (huh?). Perhaps there is a little "wiggle room" for the formulas because of this, and that's why there is a very slight discrepancy in the numbers given.

Peace,

D.

Joined

·
388 Posts

*E*=*m*/2 **V*^2

- 180 gr = 0.0116638 kg

985 f/s = 300.28 m/s

*E*= 0.0116638/2 * 300.28^2

*E*= 0.0058319 * 90168.0784

*E*= 525.8512164209599 J

J = 0.7375622 lb/ft

*E*= 387.8479672 lb/ft

Joined

·
2,078 Posts

Joined

·
16,428 Posts

Joined

·
62 Posts

Speed of sound in air at 100 degrees C (212F) = 1268 ft/sec

c = square root (gamma*R*T)

c = speed of sound in a gas

gamma = gas constant at standard temp and pressure (insert 1.4)

R = 286 (ideal gas constant)

T = absolute temperature in K (degrees C plus 273.15)

(the answer is in meters, and you have to convert to feet)

In short, a round traveling under 1050 ft/sec should be subsonic unless you intend to shoot Santa at the north pole in January. At -50C (-58F) your speed of sound drops to 980 f/sec, and Santa will hear the crack of the bullet (if you miss).

At room temperature, the speed of sound is closer to 1125-1140 ft/sec. General assumptions are made regarding air pressure, so attempts on Santa at sea level may be different than attempts at the top of a mountain. And Santa's elves pack .50BMG, so be careful out there!

(edit to correct and change "square" to "square root")

1 - 20 of 25 Posts

- This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.

Join the discussion

Springfield XD Forum

A forum community dedicated to Springfield Armory XD and XD-M series firearm owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!

Full Forum Listing
Explore Our Forums

Recommended Communities

Join now to ask and comment!