XD Talk

  • Home
  • Forum
  • Active Topics
  • Gallery
  • Social Groups
  • Search
  • Today's Posts
  • Mark Forums Read
  • Register
  • Advertise

.40 or .45?

This is a discussion on .40 or .45? within the XD-M Discussion Room - XD(M) forums, part of the XD Talk category; A 45 in a double stack striker fire gun has a father grib. Not a fan with my little hands. But I do like the ...

Old 01-21-2013, 02:38 PM   #31
XDTalk 100 Member
TakeM406's Avatar
Member #: 82435
Join Date: Nov 2012
Posts: 483
A 45 in a double stack striker fire gun has a father grib. Not a fan with my little hands. But I do like the feel of a 1911.

Sent from my layout blind
TakeM406 is offline   Reply With Quote
Remove Ads
Old 01-21-2013, 03:21 PM   #32
XDTalk Member
M1903A3's Avatar
Member #: 73178
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 60
Originally Posted by xDeRviisH View Post
I have both the 3.8 and 4.5 in the 9mm and have been recently looking into getting another firearm because I have the money to spend. I've asked a lot of people and friends what they prefer and it seems that there is a fair amount of people that like both the .40 and .45. I was hoping someone could help me with my decision. It would be for home defense and possibly conceal carry. Thanks
Hi! I think that either caliber is a great choice, and you have gotten some good reasons from others to go with one or the other.

I own an XD(m)40 compact. I find your idea to use the same basic gun for both concealed carry AND home defense to be just what I wanted, and in fact exactly what some of the marketing for the XD(m) compact guns said!! With the flush fitting magazine installed, you have a very concealable pistol, yet by switching to the extended mag, you have a full length grip JUST LIKE a "standard" full sized gun, plus the extra capacity. And honestly, at distances typical of defensive use and/or home defense use, the 3.8" barrel is in no way a problem, in fact most would be hard pressed to detect an accuracy difference between these and a longer barrel, especially under the circumstances you (and I) envision having to use them under! So I totally agree with the possibility of two guns in one.

As far as the 40 vs. 45 debate goes, what is interesting that often nowadays THIS is the debate, rather than 9 vs. 45! I have shot all of these calibers extensively in various guns, and here is what I can tell you from my perspective. This is also backed up by a lot of the people who I know that shoot. The 9mm recoil is quick, snappy, fast. 45 tends to be much more of a push, a hard shove, but not as "fast". But the 40, and especially in a light gun, JUMPS. It is both fast and hard, but not uncontrollable. It is just something to get used to. Whether or not this is an issue for you may well depend on how well you can grip the gun, for example if with a short grip you can only get two fingers on it. One other poster made an excellent point quoting the average chamber pressures of the guns, and believe me you can detect that the 40S&W is a higher pressure round.

But what about ballistics? We all know that the days of the 9mm being disliked are gone. Modern bullets are vast improvements over what used to be available, and the 9mm is a fine choice for any defensive use. The 40, with its interesting developmental history, has always seemed to me like an excercise in intentionally developing a round to perform well in real world circumstances, as determined by the FBI. Reading about the gun battle that prompted the invention of this round, and the subsequent development of it, (and the effect on OTHER caliber's bullet development) is great reading! I think, personally, that the 40 is the best balance of individual round power vs. total magazine capacity. BUT you are bound to be good with either 40 or 45. The 45 is a legendary round, and very rightly so.

For me, the possibility of having a short-gripped, double stack 40 that I can still conceal, AND a full length gripped extended mag gun, sold me on the XD(m)40 Compact. I feel it is a great balance of all the factors that all of us consider in buying a carry OR home defense gun: power of the round, number of rounds, magazine capacity, concealability, operability, durability.

Hope this helps!! (GOSH that was long haha)

"The very atmosphere of firearms anywhere and everywhere restrains evil interference - they deserve a place of honor with all that's good" -- George Washington

"Arms in the hands of citizens may be used at individual discretion in private self defense." -- John Adams

"A free people ought to be armed."-- George Washington
M1903A3 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 03:35 PM   #33
XDTalk 100 Member
XDMickey's Avatar
Member #: 23483
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: N. Georgia
Posts: 463
Up until 4 days ago I had a 40 and a 45 XD. I had the choice and bought another 45.
12+1 of 45 ...sweet.

Freedom Isn't Free
XDMickey is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 03:37 PM   #34
XDTalk 100 Member
drcreepyfoot's Avatar
Member #: 84404
Join Date: Dec 2012
Location: Dallas, TX
Posts: 139
I've been a fan of .40 for a long time, even more so now that ammo is easier to find than in the past. That being said, it does have some flaws, but I'm a fan of capacity. Nothing like a double stacked .40 magazine.
drcreepyfoot is online now   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 04:03 PM   #35
XDTalk 100 Member
Member #: 84034
Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 316
In the XDm Compact...is there a width difference in .40 and .45?
firecadet613 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 04:08 PM   #36
XDTalk 3K Member

YoopermikeXDM's Avatar
Member #: 54620
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: U.P. of MI
Posts: 3,924
Originally Posted by firecadet613 View Post
In the XDm Compact...is there a width difference in .40 and .45?
.05 I do believe that the grip in the 45 is wider in that aspect. The 9mm and 40cal I think share the same frames.
DISCLAIMER - watch out for crude sarcasm and frequent glock bashing!

Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after. ~Henry David Thoreau

Soil that is dirty grows the countless things. A river that is too pure contains no fish. Thus as a mature person you properly include and retain a measure of grime.
YoopermikeXDM is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 04:24 PM   #37
XDTalk 2K Member
USMCBill's Avatar
Member #: 51107
Join Date: Dec 2010
Location: Florida
Posts: 2,093
US Marines 86-94
NRA Life Member
GOA Life Member
MCL Member

"You cannot exaggerate about the Marines. They are convinced to the point of arrogance, that they are the most ferocious fighters on earth - and the amusing thing about it is that they are."
Father Kevin Keaney, 1st Marine Div Chaplain, Korean War
USMCBill is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 05:56 PM   #38
XDTalk 100 Member
Member #: 36528
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: missouri
Posts: 337
45. If its good enough for john moses browning its good enough for me
meaty is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 06:16 PM   #39
XDTalk 2K Member
Member #: 17883
Join Date: May 2007
Location: middle georgia
Posts: 2,630
.45 proven in action for over 100 yrs + and counting

i'd say the .45 - proven in action for over 100 yrs +!

M1911 pistol - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

here is a snipet:
American units fighting Moro guerrillas during the Philippine-American War using the then-standard Colt M1892 revolver, in .38 Long Colt, found it to be unsuitable for the rigors of jungle warfare, particularly in terms of stopping power, as the Moros had very high battle morale and frequently used drugs to inhibit the sensation of pain.[9] The U.S. Army briefly reverted to using the M1873 single-action revolver in .45 Colt caliber, which had been standard during the late 19th century; the heavier bullet was found to be more effective against charging tribesmen.[10] The problems prompted the then–Chief of Ordnance, General William Crozier, to authorize further testing for a new service pistol.[10]
Following the 1904 Thompson-LaGarde pistol round effectiveness tests, Colonel John T. Thompson stated that the new pistol "should not be of less than .45 caliber" and would preferably be semi-automatic in operation.[10] This led to the 1906 trials of pistols from six firearms manufacturing companies (namely, Colt, Bergmann, Deutsche Waffen und Munitionsfabriken (DWM), Savage Arms Company, Knoble, Webley, and White-Merril.[10]
getanxd is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-21-2013, 06:27 PM   #40
XDTalk 15K Member
Member #: 54775
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 18,155
I love my .40 cal.
Bonehead is offline   Reply With Quote

Lower Navigation
Go Back   XDTalk Forums - Your XD/XD(m) Information Source! » XD Talk » XD-M Discussion Room - XD(M)

Search tags for this page

tampa browning buckmark


why buy .45 over 40

Click on a term to search for related topics.

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On