MSNBC's Brewer: Does Obama Stand a Chance in the Racist South?
By Lyndsi Thomas (Bio | Archive)
August 4, 2008 - 13:41 ET
Newsweek Paris bureau chief Christopher Dickey appeared as a guest on the August 4 edition of MSNBC’s “News Live” to discuss a recent trip through the South he took in order to determine “if Obama's candidacy was helping to pull people in the South together, freeing them of their histories, or pushing them apart.” During their discussion, the two journalists disparaged white Southerners who are skeptical of Obama as racists.
Responding to an inquiry by Brewer about his description of emotions in the South as “raw,” Dickey rendered any hesitations white Southerners may have with Obama as thinly-veiled racism:
The South is part of the country that’s had to deal with race as an issue for a very long time and often very painfully so the idea that Obama is a black man that may be the next President of the United States has raised hopes among African-Americans tremendously, uh, but it’s also raised a lot of concerns among whites who may not talk about it as a race question but raise lots of other issues that may in some cases be code for race.
In following up with that response, Brewer noted that Southerners often deal with the stereotype that they are all racists, yet proceeded to depict them as clinging -- I suppose bitterly along with guns and Bibles -- to racist traditions:
There are probably a lot of families, too, who are wary of that stereotype, that racist stereotype that gets slapped on the South so frequently, but in your travels, you found merchants who are selling what clearly are hurtful symbols of the South's racist past. And so how does Barack Obama really stand a chance in places where so many people do cling to their Southern, sometimes racist traditions?
The transcript of the August 4 segment, which aired at 10:37 a.m., follows:
CONTESSA BREWER, host: Barack Obama is crossing the Mason-Dixon line with a new strategy to compete in traditionally Republican states. He’s trying to win crucial southern votes. Newsweek’s Christopher Dickey took a road trip through Tennessee and Georgia and the Carolinas to find out if Barack Obama’s candidacy is bringing people together or dividing the South even further. Christopher, I suppose this is a far cry from what you're normally doing, bureau chief there in Paris.
CHRISTOPHER DICKEY, Newsweek: Well, yes, it is, but my family has very deep roots in the South so it was also like a homecoming trip.
BREWER: So, when you go there, you described emotions as being raw. What did you mean by that?
DICKEY: Well, I think the idea that we could have a black president is something that is very much on the surface in the South. The South is not the only place where race may be an issue. The South is part of the country that’s had to deal with race as an issue for a very long time and often very painfully so the idea that Obama is a black man that may be the next President of the United States has raised hopes among African-Americans tremendously, uh, but it’s also raised a lot of concerns among whites who may not talk about it as a race question but raise lots of other issues that may in some cases be code for race.
BREWER: There are probably a lot of families, too, who are wary of that stereotype, that racist stereotype that gets slapped on the South so frequently, but in your travels, you found merchants who are selling what clearly are hurtful symbols of the South's racist past. And so how does Barack Obama really stand a chance in places where so many people do cling to their Southern, sometimes racist traditions?
DICKEY: Well, I think that the real key for him is going to be whether people who don't want him as president go out and vote for McCain. The flip side of what I saw on the anti-Obama course of this trip was no McCain bumper stickers, no McCain signs in people's yards. There is not a lot of enthusiasm for McCain in the South. There's a lot of worry about Obama. So, if McCain voters stay home, and Obama can mobilize, really heavily mobilize black voters and those liberal voters who are sympathetic to his message in the South, then he might have a chance.
BREWER: What did you see in terms of resources being spent in these places where President Bush in both 2000 and 2004 swept these states?
DICKEY: Well, he did. And I think Obama’s best chance is probably in Virginia because of northern Virginia, but there are certainly resources being spent in North Carolina and in Georgia and sometimes you come across evidence of Obama at organization in places you wouldn't expect it. There was a sort of a civic fair in Crawford, Georgia, last week and there was a big Obama stand and people were canvassing for him. White people.
BREWER: In some of these places where if you look that President Bush took Georgia by 17 points, Virginia, you mentioned, 9 points there. Are these places where, with enough money, with enough voter registration that they become competitive for Barack Obama?
DICKEY: Well, that's what his campaign seems to believe, that if he puts enough money in there, if he avoids the wedge issues that Bush exploited in 2004 and 2000 then he may have a chance. Frankly, my impression is he does not. He is not likely to win North Carolina or Georgia. But we still have several weeks to go.
BREWER: Christopher Dickey, always a pleasure to see you. Thank you for coming in.
DICKEY: Thank you.
The only way you southerners can redeems yourself is to vote Obama!!!!
__________________
My savior is a carpenter, not a president.
Brewer can eat my cornbread and grits eatin Southern ass!
Maybe whites in the south are not voting for Obama because he....well.....just sucks!
__________________
"Truth is treason in the empire of lies" Ron Paul
"There is something very masculine about a stogy. In this modern age of emasculated, limp-wristed, quiche-eating nancy boys, it stands tall as one of the last icons of teeth gritting manliness." C. Gadsden
well aint it nice how they can lump all southerns together. This just gives me one more reason why I refuse to watch MSNBC.
Now have I personally witnessed racism in Alabama? Yes
Did I do anything about it? No
Should I have done something about it? No (I think that once you are that far gone there isint much I can do for ya)
I refuse to vote for him because his affiliations scare me, trust me it has nothing to do with his skin color.
I am a republican and will always vote republican.
__________________
War Eagle, fly down the field
Ever to conquer, never to yield
War Eagle, fearless and true,
Fight on you orange and blue
Go! Go! Go!
On to vict'ry, strike up the band
Give 'em hell, Give 'em hell,
Stand up and yell, Hey!
War Eagle, win for Auburn,
Power of Dixie Land!
well aint it nice how they can lump all southerns together. This just gives me one more reason why I refuse to watch MSNBC.
Now have I personally witnessed racism in Alabama? Yes
Did I do anything about it? No
Should I have done something about it? No (I think that once you are that far gone there isint much I can do for ya)
I refuse to vote for him because his affiliations scare me, trust me it has nothing to do with his skin color.
I am a republican and will always vote republican.
But if your not voting for obama, you're a racist
__________________
My savior is a carpenter, not a president.
Yea I saw that posted on here a few weeks to maybe a month ago, and that is one thing that really scares me about this election year. I'm scared to see where this country is going.
__________________
War Eagle, fly down the field
Ever to conquer, never to yield
War Eagle, fearless and true,
Fight on you orange and blue
Go! Go! Go!
On to vict'ry, strike up the band
Give 'em hell, Give 'em hell,
Stand up and yell, Hey!
War Eagle, win for Auburn,
Power of Dixie Land!
Yea I saw that posted on here a few weeks to maybe a month ago, and that is one thing that really scares me about this election year. I'm scared to see where this country is going.
well, Obama cannot run on anything because he is empty so why not cleverly use the race issue. The media is all for it, so why not?
If you get the chance...can you go to Lamberts for me and send me some thrown rolls?
__________________
My savior is a carpenter, not a president.
What if your Black, and you vote FOR Obama, just because he's Black.....
Wouldn't that ALSO be Racist, or is that OK?????
.
__________________ *************************************************
"To kill, you must know your enemy, and in this case my enemy is a varmint."
-Carl Spackler
well, Obama cannot run on anything because he is empty so why not cleverly use the race issue. The media is all for it, so why not?
If you get the chance...can you go to Lamberts for me and send me some thrown rolls?
Yea screw the media. MSNBC & CNN .
You know I have never been to Lamberts but I like the look of the place from their website. Im planing a trip to Vegas in March so sure if I can get down there ill hook you up.
__________________
War Eagle, fly down the field
Ever to conquer, never to yield
War Eagle, fearless and true,
Fight on you orange and blue
Go! Go! Go!
On to vict'ry, strike up the band
Give 'em hell, Give 'em hell,
Stand up and yell, Hey!
War Eagle, win for Auburn,
Power of Dixie Land!
You know I have never been to Lamberts but I like the look of the place from their website. Im planing a trip to Vegas in March so sure if I can get down there ill hook you up.
word - ive been there a few times. that place is gggggggggggggggggreat!
__________________
My savior is a carpenter, not a president.