Obama's real patriotism problem

[XDConvert9mm]

Obama's real patriotism problem

By Jonah Goldberg

Barack Obama has a patriotism problem that even Monday's flag-waving trip to Independence, Mo., can't squelch. And it doesn't have anything to do with his lapel pin.

In part because liberal commentators have such a hard time grasping why patriotism should be an issue at all, and the GOP is so clumsy explaining why it's important, the debate often gets boiled down to symbols. Like so much else about Obama, his position on the lapel flag changes with the needs of the moment. After 9/11, he wore it. During the debates over the Iraq war, he stopped because he saw the flag as a sign of support for President Bush. (He started wearing it again in May.) "I decided I won't wear that pin on my chest," he added in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. "Instead, I'm going to try to tell the American people what I believe will make this country great and, hopefully, that will be a testimony to my patriotism."

Read that line again: "What I believe will make this country great."

Not to sound too much like a Jewish mother, but some might respond, "What? It's not great now?"

This sense that America is in need of fixing in order to be a great country points to Obama's real patriotism problem. And it's not Obama's alone.

'Fundamentally good'

Definitions of patriotism proliferate, but in the American context patriotism must involve not only devotion to American texts (something that distinguishes our patriotism from European nationalism) but also an abiding belief in the inherent and enduring goodness of the American nation. We might need to change this or that policy or law, fix this or that problem, but at the end of the day the patriotic American believes that America is fundamentally good as it is.

It's the "good as it is" part that has vexed many on the left since at least the Progressive era. Marxists and other revolutionaries obviously don't believe entrepreneurial and religious America is good as it is. But even more mainstream figures have a problem distinguishing patriotic reform from reformation. Many progressives in the 1920s considered the American hinterlands a vast sea of yokels and boobs, incapable of grasping how much they needed what the activists were selling.

The Nation ran a famous series then called "These United States," in which smug emissaries from East Coast cities chronicled the "backward" attitudes of what today would be called fly-over country. One correspondent proclaimed that in "backwoods" New York (i.e. outside the Big Apple): "Resistance to change is their most sacred principle." If that was their attitude to New York, it shouldn't surprise that they felt even worse about the South. One author explained that Dixie needed nothing less than an invasion of liberal "missionaries" so that the "light of civilization" might finally be glimpsed down there. These authors simply assumed, writes intellectual historian Christopher Lasch, that " 'breaking with the past' was the precondition of cultural and political advance." Even today, writes Time's Joe Klein, "This is a chronic disease among Democrats, who tend to talk more about what's wrong with America than what's right."

Echoes of these attitudes can be found in Obama's now infamous explanation that "bitter" working-class rural voters won't embrace him because they "cling" to God, guns and bigotry. But Obama's sometimes messianic rhetoric about "remaking" America — and the explicitly revolutionary aesthetics of his campaign — also rings a bell. "I am absolutely certain," he proclaimed upon clinching the Democratic nomination, "that generations from now, we will be able to look back and tell our children that this was the moment when we began to provide care for the sick and good jobs to the jobless; this was the moment when the rise of the oceans began to slow and our planet began to heal." So wait, America never provided care for the sick or good jobs for the jobless until St. Barack arrived? That doesn't sound like the country most Americans think of when they wave their flags on the Fourth of July.

Obama went on to say that he will "remake" the country. Well, what if you don't want it remade? And Michelle Obama — who believes America is "downright mean" and is proud of America for the first time because of her husband's success — insists that Barack will make you "work" for change and that he will "demand that you, too, be different." What if you don't want to work for Obama's change? What if you don't want to be "different"?

[XDConvert9mm]

Part 2

America's 'Jedi Knight'

Liberals might giggle at what to them sounds like paranoia. But if you aren't already entranced by Obama, Obamania can seem not only vaguely anti-American but also downright otherworldly. Star Wars creator George Lucas recently proclaimed that it's "reasonably obvious" Obama is a Jedi Knight. Mark Morford, a particularly loopy San Francisco Chronicle columnist, says Obama isn't really "one of us." Rather, he's a "Lightworker," the sort of being who can help us find "a new way of being on the planet." Self-help guru Deepak Chopra insists that an Obama victory would bring about "a quantum leap in American consciousness." Even NBC's Chris Matthews has been entranced by Obama's Jedi mind tricks. Obamania, he says, is "bigger than Kennedy. … This is the New Testament."

The notion that what America needs is a redeemer figure to "remake" America from scratch isn't necessarily unpatriotic. But for lots of Americans who like America the way it is, it's sometimes hard to tell when it isn't.

Obama's real patriotism problem - Yahoo! News

I do believe that this country needs a good bit of work to fix the problems we have. A total remake in the image Obama has projected not just during the General Election run but in the primaries and before, no thank you.

I think the centrists moves he's been making lately have to be recognized for what they are, political maneuvers to get to the Office. Yes, McCain has certainly been doing it too. I think the basic tenets Obama supported in the past are much more potentially harmful to this Nation than those of McCain and show his true colors if one looks back far enough.

[trik396]

There are so many reasons to hate Obama... keep em' coming.

[Brickboy240]

The left in America has disdain for regular peoples living outside NY, LA and Chicago?

...this is news?

I enjoyed Goldberg's book, "Liberal Fascism" and think it should be required reading for many around here...but...in this article I think he is re-hashing alot of things we already knew about Obama and his ilk.

Nothing new really...who does not know this stuff?

- Brickboy240

[XDConvert9mm]

Originally Posted by Brickboy240

The left in America has disdain for regular peoples living outside NY, LA and Chicago?

...this is news?

I enjoyed Goldberg's book, "Liberal Fascism" and think it should be required reading for many around here...but...in this article I think he is re-hashing alot of things we already knew about Obama and his ilk.

Nothing new really...who does not know this stuff?

- Brickboy240

According to the polls, a majority of voters.

[yeahYeah]

Only a democrat has to constantly prove his/her patriotism and desire to do what is in Americas best interest.

[trik396]

Originally Posted by Brickboy240

The left in America has disdain for regular peoples living outside NY, LA and Chicago?

...this is news?

I enjoyed Goldberg's book, "Liberal Fascism" and think it should be required reading for many around here...but...in this article I think he is re-hashing alot of things we already knew about Obama and his ilk.

Nothing new really...who does not know this stuff?

- Brickboy240

There is much not known about Obama, though.... one of my posts about Obama and Chicago's public housing hasn't gotten much response, in part, because I feel the link is almost ten pages long. If you want to see corruption related to Obama and have a new different reason to dislike him, read it all.

He is as corrupt or more so than other politicians that come from my lovely state. Daley, Blagojevich, Obama, are all one and the same.