All Things XD(M)™ Posted Here... - Page 55 - XDTalk Forums - Your HS2000/SA-XD Information Source!

DPGDirk · 05-16-2008, 08:45 AM

WHAT'S a lot of extra money???

Do you think these guns will stay that high?
It's a new product. It's common for them to go at or near retail prices at first.
No doubt, the prices will come down some after these guns are available widely and the "new" wears off.

I think it's sad to say that SA is simply selling "gimmicks"- especially when folks haven't even shot the gun.

The slide tapering DOES make sense- whether it makes a big difference for an particular individual or not.
I would think a narrower slide top would just make the gun "look" slimmer for the shooter(while shooting) - similar to a 1911 (if you will) or other narrower gun.
I used to own some 1911's, and that blocky fatter slide top of the XD took a little getting used to for me.

BTW- how much does a Barsto barrel add to the cost of an XD now?
I don't think the price is out of line.
I agree that not pulling the trigger to disassemble the gun is meaningless.

Overall, I like the gun. I can say that I'd have no reservations about buying that gun in a .45.

What WOULD it take for some to accept this as a NEW gun?
A complete redesign?

If we all like the original XD so much, (and we do) then let's be glad they didn't completely redesign it, but maybe just made some good refinements to a great gun.

Also, if Scott does a trigger job and really likes the gun, I think I'll take a GM status shooters opinion any time. Sounds like a trigger job away from being a sweet shooter!

tomfoolery · 05-16-2008, 08:50 AM

Eh....i'm not really sold on it.

The original XD model with a match barrel, dawson sights, and practice is just as good as the new M. I know the price will drop eventually which may spark my interest a little more.

Ishpeck · 05-16-2008, 09:00 AM

Alright, the XD-M is ugly. Freaking ugly. I can't stand to look at it.

Except I'm tempted to give it a try anyway. Reduced take-up and reset on the trigger and the match grade barrel are worth seriously looking into.

The other stuff is just "we wish we were the M&P" happening -- right down to the M&P's ugliness.

Trigger and barrel = everything.

Ugliness may actually mean better.

"Haha! You just got shot with an ugly gun! Now you're hurt AND humiliated! S'what you get for trying to eat my children."

Wild Rice · 05-16-2008, 09:13 AM

The new XD-M has the same cheesy stamped sheet-metal ejector that they are now installing in 2008 XD models. I think I will pass on the XD-M for this and other reasons. I don't like paying more for a gun with el cheapo parts. Where is the Value??? I won't be buying anymore XD's either. My brand new 2008 XD-45 Compact shipped with a cheesy loose-fitting stamped ejector. I replaced it myself at my own expense. If Springfield is using cheaper parts and raising prices, that means some exec is getting richer and we are getting inferior guns at inflated prices.

dogboy · 05-16-2008, 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DPGDirk

What WOULD it take for some to accept this as a NEW gun?
A complete redesign?

If we all like the original XD so much, (and we do) then let's be glad they didn't completely redesign it, but maybe just made some good refinements to a great gun.

All it would take for me to accept the gun is the longer barrel (not match) and slide (with the new contour and sights), keep the same grip (no inserts) and the same length (yeah, same capacity), add a thumb safety, and don't add the extra money for a match barrel. I'd buy it then.

In reality, though, I'd accept the XD-m as is, if it didn't have the match barrel and associated extra cost. I could overlook the rest of the things I don't like for less money. But i'd still prefer a thumb safety, for something really different.

**Loves2Shoot** · 05-16-2008, 10:33 AM

On the trigger jobs, I can do them right off the bat, but I'm decide HOW I want to do it. Most likely I will remove the "take down" feature, as it adds a bunch of crap for little reward. Who really can't pull the trigger to take the slide off and want 5 more pieces in their fire control system besides bean counters who aren't shooters?

The XDm did shoot really nice and I do think it will make a nice addition to the XD line.

**Loves2Shoot** · 05-16-2008, 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Small Arms

My source is Tom Gresham. Who clearly appears to have more knowledge regarding the new XD-M than anybody else I've seen here.

People who know what SA specifically plans on doing are NOT likely to be announcing it on public forums before it is approved to do so. I know SA folks visit this forum, and you don't see them posting their future plans.

I think Tom's reply and disclaimer cleared up his opinion about what is "likely" a bit.

DPGDirk · 05-16-2008, 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Loves2Shoot

The XDm did shoot really nice and I do think it will make a nice addition to the XD line.

So, having shot this gun, what's your opinion on the mag release grooves?
Do you find it easier to drop the mag on the new gun?

I'm also interested in that reconfigured slide release. Is it easier to actuate than the older flat unit?
My thumb is just short enough that dropping the slide release with my thumb is kind of hard if I don't do it just right.

and what's the scoop on the stamped ejector that ricer was talking about?
Any concerns there? I'm not sure which part he's talking about there...

Thanks!

**Loves2Shoot** · 05-16-2008, 10:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DPGDirk

So, having shot this gun, what's your opinion on the mag release grooves?
Do you find it easier to drop the mag on the new gun?

I'm also interested in that reconfigured slide release. Is it easier to actuate than the older flat unit?
My thumb is just short enough that dropping the slide release with my thumb is kind of hard if I don't do it just right.

and what's the scoop on the stamped ejector that ricer was talking about?
Any concerns there? I'm not sure which part he's talking about there...

Thanks!

The grip fit me better, I don't know the grooves do anything for me, but I use an extended release anyway on the XD and would use one on the XDm.

The slide release is nice and I like the profile of the take down lever better also.

The ejector is the same one they use in the XD models and I have had no issues of it not working as well as the cast part.

kaotik78 · 05-16-2008, 10:59 AM

Looks like a XD had relations with a S&W M&P pistol, then a Taurus came along and asked to join in the fun.... ick, no thanks.

05-16-2008, 08:45 AM	#541
DPGDirk XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Rose Hill, KS Posts: 293	WHAT'S a lot of extra money??? Do you think these guns will stay that high? It's a new product. It's common for them to go at or near retail prices at first. No doubt, the prices will come down some after these guns are available widely and the "new" wears off. I think it's sad to say that SA is simply selling "gimmicks"- especially when folks haven't even shot the gun. The slide tapering DOES make sense- whether it makes a big difference for an particular individual or not. I would think a narrower slide top would just make the gun "look" slimmer for the shooter(while shooting) - similar to a 1911 (if you will) or other narrower gun. I used to own some 1911's, and that blocky fatter slide top of the XD took a little getting used to for me. BTW- how much does a Barsto barrel add to the cost of an XD now? I don't think the price is out of line. I agree that not pulling the trigger to disassemble the gun is meaningless. Overall, I like the gun. I can say that I'd have no reservations about buying that gun in a .45. What WOULD it take for some to accept this as a NEW gun? A complete redesign? If we all like the original XD so much, (and we do) then let's be glad they didn't completely redesign it, but maybe just made some good refinements to a great gun. Also, if Scott does a trigger job and really likes the gun, I think I'll take a GM status shooters opinion any time. Sounds like a trigger job away from being a sweet shooter! __________________ XD .45- 4" service model Polished Barrel, Tru-Glo F/O Sights, Springer Carry Trigger, Factory Clean-up, Extended mag release, etc XD 9mm Service Bi-Tone w/ Tru-Glo F/O Sights & Polished Barrel (Springer Candidate) Kahr PM-45 w/ polished barrel and meprolights http://www.precisionfirearmfinishing.com

05-16-2008, 08:50 AM	#542
tomfoolery XDTalk 3K Member Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Cincinnati Posts: 3,262	Eh....i'm not really sold on it. The original XD model with a match barrel, dawson sights, and practice is just as good as the new M. I know the price will drop eventually which may spark my interest a little more. __________________ "It is better to die on your feet than live on your knees." "One is none, two is one, and three is just a good time." Clint Smith, referring to the number of guns you carry daily.

05-16-2008, 09:00 AM	#543
Ishpeck XDTalk 3K Member Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Earth Posts: 3,578	Alright, the XD-M is ugly. Freaking ugly. I can't stand to look at it. Except I'm tempted to give it a try anyway. Reduced take-up and reset on the trigger and the match grade barrel are worth seriously looking into. The other stuff is just "we wish we were the M&P" happening -- right down to the M&P's ugliness. Trigger and barrel = everything. Ugliness may actually mean better. "Haha! You just got shot with an ugly gun! Now you're hurt AND humiliated! S'what you get for trying to eat my children." __________________ Because Godwin's law hasn't been beaten hard enough today: I don't think it's any coincidence that one of the forms of "witholdings" in my paycheck is labeled "SS." http://me.ishpeck.net/index.php?P=2020_vision Last edited by Ishpeck : 05-16-2008 at 09:06 AM.

05-16-2008, 10:33 AM	#546
Loves2Shoot XDTalk 2K Member Join Date: May 2006 Location: Bend, OR Posts: 2,426	On the trigger jobs, I can do them right off the bat, but I'm decide HOW I want to do it. Most likely I will remove the "take down" feature, as it adds a bunch of crap for little reward. Who really can't pull the trigger to take the slide off and want 5 more pieces in their fire control system besides bean counters who aren't shooters? The XDm did shoot really nice and I do think it will make a nice addition to the XD line. __________________ www.SpringerPrecision.com

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

05-16-2008, 09:13 AM	#544
Wild Rice XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 188	The new XD-M has the same cheesy stamped sheet-metal ejector that they are now installing in 2008 XD models. I think I will pass on the XD-M for this and other reasons. I don't like paying more for a gun with el cheapo parts. Where is the Value??? I won't be buying anymore XD's either. My brand new 2008 XD-45 Compact shipped with a cheesy loose-fitting stamped ejector. I replaced it myself at my own expense. If Springfield is using cheaper parts and raising prices, that means some exec is getting richer and we are getting inferior guns at inflated prices.

05-16-2008, 10:59 AM	#550
kaotik78 XDTalk Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: Manchester, NH Posts: 93	Looks like a XD had relations with a S&W M&P pistol, then a Taurus came along and asked to join in the fun.... ick, no thanks.