Gun for son - XD 9mm or G19? - Page 3 - XDTalk Forums - Your HS2000/SA-XD Information Source!

briang2ad · 12-27-2007, 03:28 PM

Read my 45 Compact posts. IN 45, I prefer the XD. But... I may have my son get the 19. I felt one in a showroom the other day, the that trigger was CRISP. The 19 feels OK in my sons hands. I will have him compare again, and see. I am TOO CHEAP to pay to shoot, AND pay to rent - would have to in my area. Besides - the guns are not THAT different, and both good values. My price point is SO good on the G19, and they are simpler and easier to work on. (If he eventually hates it, I'll at least break even on a sale). The only thing I don't like about my XD 45C is it is a bit complex - even the slide is complex. I DON'T expect to have to DO anything, so its OK. But, on the G19, I could help my son fix and play all day.

TechGuy · 12-28-2007, 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Plinkomatic

Since this is a flame free thread, don't overlook the CZ75 or Browning Hi-Power.

I have the CZ 75 P-01 in 9mm and it is NICE. Very good natual feel / point to it. But that was not one of the original choices.

Between the Glock and XD, both are very good and highly dependable, no issues eating ammo for either. So have him hold or better yet shoot both. My money is on the XD. Size wise, the grip / point on the XD is IMHO better. I have an XD45, got it over a Glock for the same reason. Have been told over and over, get what feels best and the XD wins more often than not.

lora84 · 12-28-2007, 03:52 PM

I think you are making an excellent choice in the G19. Utterly reliable and breaks down into 3 pieces for cleaning. Like you said, if he ends hating the pistol you should easily be able to recoup your money.

briang2ad · 12-28-2007, 05:23 PM

Its tough. IF the P01 came with a MANUAL safety like my other CZs, I'd steer him that way. But, I really like my XD 45 Compact. Articles like this: http://www.chucktaylorasaa.com/SpringfieldXD9.html make the XD sound sooo good, but I do think the G19 is so simple and like I said the price point for me is great. I do kinda like the thick rails and grip safety. Too bad the XD is so much more complex.

OTOH, the 45 was probably a good move. The size factor and grip on the XD is so good. Although, I wonder how I'll find the G30 SF? I did handle the 21SF, and while it felt pretty good, the XD felt better.

Anyone discern a ral difference in shooting them as far as muzzle flip because of the supposedly higher bore axis of the XD? (In 9mm - G19 vs. XD9mm).

danp · 12-28-2007, 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by briang2ad

Its tough. IF the P01 came with a MANUAL safety like my other CZs, I'd steer him that way. But, I really like my XD 45 Compact. Articles like this: http://www.chucktaylorasaa.com/SpringfieldXD9.html make the XD sound sooo good, but I do think the G19 is so simple and like I said the price point for me is great. I do kinda like the thick rails and grip safety. Too bad the XD is so much more complex.

OTOH, the 45 was probably a good move. The size factor and grip on the XD is so good. Although, I wonder how I'll find the G30 SF? I did handle the 21SF, and while it felt pretty good, the XD felt better.

Anyone discern a ral difference in shooting them as far as muzzle flip because of the supposedly higher bore axis of the XD? (In 9mm - G19 vs. XD9mm).

I've shot both the Glock 17 and XD-9 at the same time and could not tell any differance in recoil. Just out of curiosity, how old is your son? I assume he is fairly young, hence the 9mm instead of the 45 you already shoot but if this is his first handgun, you may want to go with a good .22lr.

briang2ad · 12-28-2007, 05:58 PM

He wants a 9mm. Of course, it will be 'mine' for a time. But he'll shoot it and take care of it.

danp · 12-28-2007, 07:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by briang2ad

He wants a 9mm. Of course, it will be 'mine' for a time. But he'll shoot it and take care of it.

Gotcha. 16 is a great age for a 9mm. Enough kick to be a "real" gun, but light enough to be fun and a high CDI factor.

pinpointshot · 12-28-2007, 09:18 PM

Being 16 myself I have a XD9SC and When I went to look at guns it was between the M&P, GLOCK, or XD. I liked the feel of the XD more and the extra features it has. I liked the grip angle a hole lot better also. I ultimately chose the XD and I had no regrets.

With the glock because of the price it is probably a 1st generation without the rail or the finger grooves in the front of the grip. That will mean it has lower resale value and is not as wanted as the new 3rd generation models.

9mm is a great caliber for his age to start out with buts thats not the reason I got one. It was cheaper than my .357 to shoot so I could practice a lot more.

thomasward00 · 12-28-2007, 09:52 PM

I just ordered my XD9 SC from Woodbury Outfitters for 399.99 plus 20 bucks shipping, after everything is said and done it will be about 100.00 cheaper than a glock, which you could put towards ammo or a tac light for him. Plus keep in mind that the xd has the supported barrel just in case he wants to eventually shoot +P.

briang2ad · 12-29-2007, 07:11 AM

and be out the door for $421. That is likely chaeper than the XD.

12-27-2007, 03:28 PM	#21
briang2ad XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 236	Leaning toward Glock Read my 45 Compact posts. IN 45, I prefer the XD. But... I may have my son get the 19. I felt one in a showroom the other day, the that trigger was CRISP. The 19 feels OK in my sons hands. I will have him compare again, and see. I am TOO CHEAP to pay to shoot, AND pay to rent - would have to in my area. Besides - the guns are not THAT different, and both good values. My price point is SO good on the G19, and they are simpler and easier to work on. (If he eventually hates it, I'll at least break even on a sale). The only thing I don't like about my XD 45C is it is a bit complex - even the slide is complex. I DON'T expect to have to DO anything, so its OK. But, on the G19, I could help my son fix and play all day.

12-28-2007, 05:23 PM	#24
briang2ad XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 236	Thanks guys... Its tough. IF the P01 came with a MANUAL safety like my other CZs, I'd steer him that way. But, I really like my XD 45 Compact. Articles like this: http://www.chucktaylorasaa.com/SpringfieldXD9.html make the XD sound sooo good, but I do think the G19 is so simple and like I said the price point for me is great. I do kinda like the thick rails and grip safety. Too bad the XD is so much more complex. OTOH, the 45 was probably a good move. The size factor and grip on the XD is so good. Although, I wonder how I'll find the G30 SF? I did handle the 21SF, and while it felt pretty good, the XD felt better. Anyone discern a ral difference in shooting them as far as muzzle flip because of the supposedly higher bore axis of the XD? (In 9mm - G19 vs. XD9mm).

12-28-2007, 05:58 PM	#26
briang2ad XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 236	He is 16... He wants a 9mm. Of course, it will be 'mine' for a time. But he'll shoot it and take care of it.

12-28-2007, 09:18 PM	#28
pinpointshot XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Evansville, Indiana Posts: 199	Being 16 myself I have a XD9SC and When I went to look at guns it was between the M&P, GLOCK, or XD. I liked the feel of the XD more and the extra features it has. I liked the grip angle a hole lot better also. I ultimately chose the XD and I had no regrets. With the glock because of the price it is probably a 1st generation without the rail or the finger grooves in the front of the grip. That will mean it has lower resale value and is not as wanted as the new 3rd generation models. 9mm is a great caliber for his age to start out with buts thats not the reason I got one. It was cheaper than my .357 to shoot so I could practice a lot more. __________________ " If you dont have anything nice to say...You must be talkin about Hillary Clinton." Jeff Foxworthy

12-28-2007, 09:52 PM	#29
thomasward00 XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: S.E. Louisiana Posts: 175	I just ordered my XD9 SC from Woodbury Outfitters for 399.99 plus 20 bucks shipping, after everything is said and done it will be about 100.00 cheaper than a glock, which you could put towards ammo or a tac light for him. Plus keep in mind that the xd has the supported barrel just in case he wants to eventually shoot +P. __________________ Geaux Tigers! H&K USP 9mm H&K P2000 SK .357 Sig & .40 S&W H&K USP Compact .357 Sig H&K P7 PSP 9mm

12-28-2007, 03:52 PM	#23
lora84 XDTalk 1K Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: NC Posts: 1,330	I think you are making an excellent choice in the G19. Utterly reliable and breaks down into 3 pieces for cleaning. Like you said, if he ends hating the pistol you should easily be able to recoup your money.

12-29-2007, 07:11 AM	#30
briang2ad XDTalk 100 Member Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 236	I can get the G19 at LE price and be out the door for $421. That is likely chaeper than the XD.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode